Business Plans and Budgets

I recently participated in a couple of online workshops offered by the SCORE Association. SCORE offers free counseling and advice for America's small businesses and entrepreneurs. The workshops were titled Developing a Business Plan and Preparing a Cash Budget. I'll take a few of the points presented in the workshops and apply them to the music business.

Business Plans
The first major point made in the workshop was that "business planning is considered an oxymoron to the free flowing business style of the entrepreneur." This is especially true for musicians, as an artist is generally considered an entrepreneur.

Most aspiring music artists do not have a business plan. The usual "plan" is to write some songs, record some tracks, promote the music on the street, and hope for success. Because the majority of aspiring artists have this mindset, the majority never succeed.

The lack of planning is not exclusive to artists. There are even those who form a "record label" without having a clear plan. Spend any time as a musician on MySpace and one will discover a number of individuals claiming to be "CEO" of a record label that they recently formed. These are labels in name only and are not legitimate businesses since they lack a plan.

As the workshop presented, "Planning is a critical component of a successful business." If an artist or label wishes to have a chance in the industry, then a clear business plan needs to be laid out for success. A plan should be formed before writing the first song or recording the first track. The following are a few items that the plan should cover:

Financials
Gather together various financial information concerning the music industry. You will want to know the cost for studio time and the average spent for a complete project, including mastering.

If you will be selling CDs, you will want to know the cost for manufacturing a CD at various volumes. More than likely you will need to purchase the lowest volume amount unless you already have 1,000 fans ready to purchase your album. Also, find out the cost for distribution unless you will be direct selling your product.

Customer Base
Many times an artist knows their target audience, or at least thinks they do. Be sure to research to find out who will more than likely purchase your product. A hip hop artist could assume that hip hop fans will be their customer base. It however takes a little more research and specifics to be successful with marketing your music.

Perhaps your target audience is located in a specific region. Perhaps they are avid MySpace or Facebook users. Perhaps they only purchase music within a certain price range. By discovering who the audience is that will actually purchase your music, you will be a step ahead on marketing.

Competition
Your potential fans only have so much money for purchasing music and so much time to listen to it. There will be other artists vying for your fans. Research to discover what advantages you will have over competing artists. Then plan to capitalize on your advantages and use them to become successful in a competitive market.

Operations
This can be summed up as what is required for running your music business from day to day. Most musicians really don't think about the daily tasks or routines they go through for managing their music career. Take time to make a list of of the tasks needed to operate, and consciously plan and improve upon those actions to increase success.

Future Plans
Ask a musician their future plans and they more than likely will tell you, "I want to have a full time career as a musician." That is a great goal, but it is not a plan. A plan is a path for reaching that goal. Put in place tangible plans of action that can empower you to reach the future goals that you have.

According to the workshop, it is estimated that 90% of businesses fail in the first 2 years. Usually the failure is attributed to the lack of planning. Determine to be the minority of artists that succeed by creating a business plan today.

Cash Budget
Every music artist or label should develop a clear plan for both cash intake and spending. This is known as a Cash Budget or Cash Forecast. A budget helps to determine "short term credit needs" and the "ability to pay debt/expenses." It is a "written account of cash inflows/outflows."

Earlier I discussed the financials of a business plan. This is where those numbers come into play. You will want to figure in profits from music and merchandise sales. Also, over time you will need to readjust the amount of income you expect as you begin to collect data on the sale of your product. As you begin to have a visual of your overall cash flow coming in and going out, you can effectively plan for expenses and determine your financial needs.

The workshop suggests that all businesses calculate a cash reserve, which is a "minimum balance of cash" to always have on hand. They further suggest the amount be "large enough for operating costs for several months." This may seem daunting to an aspiring artist. I would suggest that if the artist is maintaining a job while building their career, they consider their employment income as part of the cash reserve until their music career fully kicks off.

For a more in-depth look at business plans or budgets, view one of the many helpful workshops provided by SCORE.

Do You Need a Team?

Advances in digital music technology, coupled with the use of the Internet for marketing and distribution, empowers the independent music artist to build a music career that in the past would have been impossible. The claim in recent years has been that an individual musician no longer needs record labels or professional studios—the process of music production can take place entirely from the comfort of one's home using a personal computer.


This has lead to many aspiring artists having a maverick mentality. They feel that they are in complete control of their future and can launch their career with the push of a few buttons. This ideology is based on the flawed assumption that the artist has all knowledge and skills necessary for success in all aspects of the music business and can accurately identify the views and opinions of others.

Every successful person in history, whether in music or business in general, has only achieved success through the cooperation of people. A team is necessary in order for an artist to reach his or her desired goals.

Everyone, including the self-proclaimed maverick, has a team around them. The first step is to identify your current team. The people on your team may not be what would first come to mind when considering a music business team. Diane Kennedy writes in her book Loopholes of the Rich:

List the people you spend the most time with—your family, friends, co-wokers, and so on. Try to list at least five people. Now, next to each person's name, write the experience this person has had in what you want to achieve. (p. 33)

She goes on to write:

After you prepare the list, look at it with a critical eye. Are these people the advisors you need for the next step on your personal path to financial freedom? Do they have the needed experience to support your decisions and critically analyze them? (p. 33)

Every person in our life will be an influence and give us advice whether good or bad. Diane states that we need to understand their point of view. Are they narrow minded, not able to see the potential and vision that you see? Does their perspective cause them to provide negative comments? Once you understand the current influence in your life, you can move on to "Building a Team That Supports You." Diane says, "You have a team around you already. The difference is that now you have the opportunity to make a conscious decision about who should be on your team." She then presents the question and next step in the process: "Who Do You Want on Your Team?" (p. 32-33)

In his article, Assembling an Entertainment Industry Team, Anthony Berman lists 5 possible members for your music team:

The Personal Manager
Anthony states, "The personal manager is often the focal point between the other team members and the artist. Generally speaking, a manager's duties involve advising, counseling and guiding the artist towards the furtherance of his or her career." The manager can be the most powerful member of the team. "Management agreements typically seek to grant a manager a power-of-attorney provision which can be quite broad or narrow depending on the negotiating strengths of the parties."

The Talent Agent
"The talent agent has one clearly defined function--------getting the artist employment. Obviously, a very crucial function since, after all, without employment, the artist has no income and cannot afford to pay rent and compensate the rest of the team." Agreements with agents are generally exclusive, meaning that all bookings for the artists must come through the agent.

The Entertainment Attorney
Anthony states:
Negotiation skills and general legal advice are only a portion of what attorneys bring to the table in the entertainment industry. Many attorneys are defacto business advisors and professional matchmakers, bringing parties together for new projects. Some attorneys administer copyrights and collect and receive funds on behalf of their clients. And, of course, when deals go sour, an attorney coordinates the litigation process to resolve the claim.
The Publicist
"Simply put, a publicist's job is to develop public awareness for an artist." A person skilled in public relations and marketing is needed in order to gain attention from the public and media for an artist and their music.

The Business Manager
"Assuming the artist has a solid income stream, a business manager (usually an accountant) is an essential member of team." Anthony further states that a business manager is more than just an accountant: "Whereas accountants generally do one or two things for their clients: taxes and/or bookkeeping, a business manager can pay the artist’s bills, help the artist collect income, do payroll, budgets, tax planning, shop for the best insurance (life and health), investment analysis, and track and audit royalty accounts."

I'll add a sixth team member to the list of essential assets for success with a music career:

The Producer
A producer is usually thought of as the person overseeing a music recording project, but can be a person with a more informal role. Some type of producer is needed at each stage of the music process to help support and guide the artist in the creation of music. Artists who have built the necessary business team, sometimes proceed to limit the music creation process to themselves individually.

There are times an artist may get stumped in producing their musical art and sometimes have a tendency to only hear something one way. Having an outside source to listen and give advice can help the artist be more productive. This second person can also provide feedback as to how the audience may perceive the music.

Through each stage of an artist's career, the needs for and financial ability to obtain various members of a team will change. The specific person filling a role will more than likely change as well as the career develops.

Later I will discuss how to find the right team members, how to evaluate the members, and how to operate with your team. For more information on teams, see chapter 3 entitled Team from Diane's book or read Blair Singer's book on team building which is listed below:

The New Way of Marketing

Chris Cox on his website, Make Your Band Famous, has a video that talks about The "New Way" Business Model. This is a summary of the video, highlighting important points that Chris makes.


Traditionally in the music industry, the person that sold the most music and was discovered by a major label, was the one considered successful. Chris claims that the playing field has changed and that artists don't need people buying their music anymore.


He says that the number one obstacle to music marketing today is "trying to make money in the past." In the past, artists were able to make a living off of music. Consumers today want to buy into a lifestyle. There is now great opportunity through Internet and social media to market and sell a product.


He explains why music is no longer that product. For an artist selling 99 cent singles online, to make a $20,000 a year living, they would need 20,000 in the sale of singles (assuming they received 100% of the sale). To reach 20,000 in sales would require a minimum of 100,000 fans. To build that fan base would require a reach of 1,000,000 potential fans. That is just for a solo artist. A band would need to multiply those numbers by three or four.


Before explaining the product to sell, he describes the methods to sell it. He states that the best marketing is fan-based marketing. Build relationships with fans and let them do the marketing for the artist. He says, "music is almost always spread from friend to friend."


He reiterates that artists should stop trying to sell music. "Music is good for many things, but making money isn't one of them" He goes on to state, "Music is the medium we use to get people to know and love you."


He believes that the product is not the music, but the artist. He says, "You can make so much more money 'leveraging your celebrity' with your fanbase." He goes on to describe the four areas that people buy into for an artist:


  1. Lifestyle
  2. Values
  3. Celebrity
  4. Story


He says that these four areas are "conveyed and spread through your music." He encourages artists to "stand for something" and "adopt a niche." Anything can be sold if the person selling has credibility. People may not love the music, but will love what the artist stands for, buying and becoming fans.


He suggests that artists develop a membership program with VIP perks such as backstage passes and becoming a part of the artist's life. This can be used to create a monthly revenue. He encourages artists to offer something of value based on a cause they connect with, having the goal to leverage their "celebrity" to obtain a $1 per month per follower.


Everyone has something that they are passionate about. More than likely there are others who hold that same passion. He said an artist's passion can be their niche, opening the doors for product and marketing.

License vs. Sales

Recently Dave Kusek, VP at Berklee College of Music, posted to his blog, Future of Music, an article entitled: Are iTunes downloads actually "licenses" rather than "sales"? The article reports that Eminem's production company sued Universal Music Group for royalties on downloaded music. Labels have been using the same contracts and royalty rates on digital music distribution that they have historically used for physical distribution mediums such as CDs. A purchase on iTunes is not considered a sale, but a purchase of a license to use the music with specific limitations. Eminem's company argues that the royalties paid should be 50%, which is the traditional royalty rate for the licensing of "masters."


What Kusek's article does not delve into is the financial breakdown of the contracts being used. The language of digital contracts have been known to resemble the traditional contracts even though some of the financial items are outdated. For example, the traditional costs of producing and manufacturing physical CDs have been left in some contracts, even though the process is not involved in digital distribution. It is a loop-hole that some labels have exploited to increase profits on digital distribution while reducing the royalties paid to artists.

For the past two decades, a copyright debate has raged over the issue of ownership of music. The recording industry has argued that consumers purchasing music do not own the music, but license its use. This has been the industries base in their fight against digital music sharing and illegal downloads. Companies were hesitant to allow their music on the Internet until retailers, such as iTunes, were able to implement Digital Rights Management on audio files, dictating the use of music by the end-user. It appears now that the industry could be shooting itself in the foot with this argument. If consumers are indeed only licensing the use of music, then artists and composers should receive their traditional share of the license, which is a 50/50 split.

As Kusek states, in the end this could produce great benefits for artists and composers. I feel that it may mutually benefit both artists and fans by reducing the tendency of labels to be overactive in signing artists. Traditionally labels have pressured their A&R departments to be focused on quantity of artists as opposed to quality. A label will budget to break even on unsuccessful acts, while the artist is cut from the roster, usually without realizing a profit from their work. With royalties based on licensing, artists might be able to receive income on unsuccessful projects and labels will focus on making each artist a success in order to make a profit or break even. This will affect fans in that they will receive a better quality of music coming from the industry.